AWKWARD scenes hit Love Island Games as exes Casey and Gabby came face-to-face for the first time since their split.
Fans are convinced the Love Island: All Stars winners are “faking it” to bag the £250k prize.
Casey O’Gorman goes on Love Island for the fourth time[/caption]
He comes face to face with his ex Gabby Allen[/caption]
Casey and Gabby first found fame on different seasons of Love Island UK.
They both returned for the spin-off Love Island: All Stars and went all the way and were crowned winners after a whirlwind romance in the villa.
The couple walked away hand-in-hand with the £50k prize – but their fairy-tale quickly crumbled once the cameras stopped rolling.
Gabby said on Love Island: Aftersun that life outside the villa exposed a gap in where they were emotionally and in terms of life goals.
She said that relationships “in the villa” are very different to “real life,” implying that the pressures and dynamics changed once cameras weren’t watching.
Gabby added that juggling her businesses made it hard to find time for a relationship, and they were “at very different stages in life.”
Their split was mutual, with a statement saying they “decided to go their separate ways romantically” while remaining friends.
The exes reunited on another spin-off show, Love Island Games, which is filmed in Fiji.
When the pair found themselves alone together in the bathroom, they addressed how “weird” it was to see each other again.
Gabby asked: “Do you think this is weird?”
Casey replied: “Yeah, it is weird. It’s like the first time we have properly seen each other since we haven’t been together.”
Gabby added: “But in Fiji instead.”
Casey joked: “Yes, and with a bunch of Americans.”
Gabby laughed, before Casey turned serious again and said: “It’s fine. I’m fine. And I hope you are?”
Love Island winners – where they are now
EVERY year Love Island opens its doors to more sexy Islanders who are hoping for a holiday romance that could turn into more.
Here we take you through all of the Love Island winners so far and what their relationship statuses are now:
2025 – The summer series of Love Island saw Toni Laites and Cach Mercer win the ITV2 reality show. STATUS: Still together.
2025 – The second series of All Stars saw Gabby Allen and Case O’Gorman scoop the crown. STATUS: Broken up.
2024 – The summer Love Island saw Mimii Ngulube and Josh Oyinsan were crowned the winners. STATUS: Broken up.
2024 – The first ever All stars spin off show was won by Molly Smith and Tom Clare. STATUS: Still together.
2023 – Jess Harding and Sammy Root took home the 50k, and won the summer 2023 Love Island. STATUS: Broken up.
2023 – The first series of 2023 saw Sanam Harrinanan and Kai Fagan crowned Love Island winners in South Africa. STATUS: Still together.
2022 – Davide Sanclimenti and Ekin-Su Cülcüloğlu’s time in the villa was anything but a smooth ride, but they managed to win the public’s hearts – and the ITV2 reality show. STATUS: Broken up.
2021 – Liam Reardon and Millie Court were announced winners of Love Island 2021. STATUS: Broken up.
2020 – The first ever winter Love Island saw Paige Turley and Finn Tapp crowned winners after falling in love on the show. STATUS: Broken up.
2019 – Series 5 saw Tommy Fury and Molly-Mae Hague runners up to winners Greg O’Shea and Amber Gill, who met in the last few days of the series. STATUS: Broken up.
2018 – It wasn’t surprising fan favourites Jack Fincham and Dani Dyer won the show, as they were strong throughout. But sadly things didn’t last. STATUS: Broken up.
2017 – Kem Cetinay and Amber Davies had lots of ups and downs in the villa but went on to win. STATUS: Broken up.
2016 – Nathan Massey and Cara De La Hoyde were together from the start of the series, and since they won the show they’ve had two kids and are married. STATUS: Still together.
2015 – Despite poor Jess Hayes being Max Morley’s second choice on the show, they did win – but they didn’t last as a couple. STATUS: Broken up.
Gabby answered: “Yeah,” rather unconvincingly, before they exchanged lingering looks.
Meanwhile, fans are convinced they both returned to the show to go all the way again and win the jackpot in the final.
Some suggested they will get back together to do this, even if it means pretending to fall for each other again.
Others think they are still together and only said they broke up to appear on the show and win again, branding them as “greedy”.
Taking to social media, one wrote: “Casey and Gabby coming back to games after winning all stars is just greedy lmfaoo.”
Another added: “Nahhh I feel like they still are together or something because they’re so comfy together like whattt.”
A third penned: “I feel like Casey and gabby have a master plan and are actually still secretly together and are gonna manipulate everyone and win. #LoveIslandGames.”
A fourth chimed in: “1000% think Casey and Gabby are scamming. They will choose each other if it comes down to it.”
Love Island Games series two will be available to watch on ITVX very soon – but series one can be streamed now.
The pair won Love Island: All Stars, splitting £50k[/caption]
They split shortly after leaving the villa and said it was “mutual”[/caption]
Fans think they are after the jackpot again[/caption]
Will they fake a relationship to win £250k on Love Island Games?[/caption]
