The show about her case might have come out on Netflix months ago, but still Reddit is coming up with new scenarios surrounding what might have happened to Amy Bradley. Reddit was investigating the case way before Netflix, and it will continue to long afterwards.
In March 1998, Amy had been on a family holiday on a Royal Caribbean cruise ship. She was last seen on the family cabin’s balcony, after a night out on the boat. Since then, there have been a number of potential sightings. Some people think Amy fell overboard, others think she was trafficked.
A bunch of forums have now started – to discuss the latest news, and all the theories surrounding her case. One is the AmyLynnBradley Reddit, which is so big it featured in the Netflix show. In a post this week, a user on there shared four new “scenarios” about what might have happened.
via Netflix
‘We may just be searching for the wrong identity’
“New potential theories on Amy,” the post was captioned. “I’ve thought a lot about this case since way before the Netflix doc. I have a couple scenarios I wonder if people consider as well.” The post then listed four bullet points, explaining some theories, with their newly added context.
They said: “She did not fall off the ship, but was lured into a bedroom with a staff member. Potentially not Yellow, but someone else who isn’t even known and that’s how they got away with it.
“Jaz [the woman pictured on a site for sex workers that was believed to be Amy] is Amy, but she was handed from one business to another. Perhaps she is still trafficked, but no longer in the Caribbean, and likely not for her body. Perhaps she is used for free labor, even.
“Amy is alive, even if she is 50. But with what she was lovingly described by friends and family – outgoing, magnetic, athletic, creative, and overall a fighter – I think we need to understand how her personality would likely change. A fighter would try to make herself small and compliant in situations like that to stay alive. She definitely still could be all that again with a better situation and the right help- but we need to keep in mind she could be fully compliant and no longer asking people for help. She could be trying to hide herself as well. Unfortunately.”
via Netflix
The last bullet point is a bit more far-fetched, but theorised: “Amy definitely has long hair, and her skin could look different after a life in the Caribbean. She could have been injured while in someone else’s care and in a wheelchair. It’s possible her lazy eye grew more noticeable with age. She could be disguised as a man.”
The post concluded: “And the most important thing? Amy could be anyone by now. But that gives hope that she could be easily seen, we may just be searching for the wrong identity.”
Amy Bradley Is Missing is available on Netflix now. For all the latest Netflix news and drops, like The Holy Church of Netflix on Facebook.
